Alaska Outdoor Supersite: Alaska outdoor information
Home
Site Map
Directory -- Businesses serving the Alaska outdoors industry
Areas -- Information about Alaska outdoor areas
Forum
Fishing -- Information about fishin in Alaska
Hunting -- Information about Alaska hunting
Magazine -- Articles and photos about the Alaska outdoors
Products
Who is OAC?
   
* New on
  OutdoorsDirectory.com
* News & tips by email:
  Alaska Outdoors mailing list
* Email notification of new
  Alaska books and video

 

Terrain Navigator
CD ROM topographic map coverage for ALL of Alaska

 Terrain Navigator 2001

Click for more information


Complete Catalogs

Alaska Hunting Books
Alaska Fishing Books
Alaska Travel Books

Plan Your
Alaska Trip
with The Milepost

The Milepost

Click here for more information or to
order your copy


Hunting forum

The Alaska
Hunting Forum

[ Return to Contents | Post a Reply | Post a new message ]


Recommendations vs Private Practices
Posted by Michael Strahan on Mar 01 2006
Here's a bone to chew on fellas,

I submit that we should exercise a conservative approach above what we might actually do in the field (assuming we have a high level of proficiency), when we're recommending, in a public forum, what someone else should do.  The last thing I'm going to do is suggest to someone I don't even know that they should take a head-on shot on anything.  As soon as I do that, someone who really should not be taking that shot will become emboldened do that and more, with the result that he'll either abandon the wounded animal or spend the rest of his hunt in a futile search for it.  No thanks.

I have not always successfully held to this standard, but if you're going to write in a public forum, it's generally a best practice to make conservative recommendations to strangers, the skills of whom you are not aware.  I'm not going to tell you whether I've taken this shot, because someone will use that information to justify something they should not do.  What I WILL tell you is that I have never lost an animal that I have personally shot.  I'm not bragging about that, I've been fortunate to have what I consider to be an unusual track record in that regard.  Some of that is simply being in the right place at the right time.  Additionally, I get as close as I can, I know EXACTLY what my weapon will do at that yardage, and I ALWAYS look for a rest to shoot from.  I can categorically state without hesitation that I have NEVER taken a shot at big game and "hoped" or "wondered" what would happen as a result, yet to hear some of the stories of my peers I sometimes wonder if this is a common practice.  I'd rather take no shot at all than a marginal one, and as a result I have missed several opportunities to take game that is, as far as I know, still growing larger antlers each year that goes by.  Fine by me.  That leaves another animal in the woods for both of us to hunt.

I respect folks who have the skills to take these sort of shots and consistently kill game this way, however I question the wisdom of sharing such experiences here.  No disrespect intended to anyone.

-Mike

Previous: ? shot shphtr Mar 01 2006
Next: Ethical shot placement Michael Strahan Mar 02 2006

Message Thread:


Post a Reply

Posting to this forum is now disabled. Please visit our new forums


Alaska outdoors ~ home | Areas | Magazine | Directory | Alaska outdoors forums | Alaska boating
Alaska hunting | Alaska fishing | Alaska Outdoors Store | Site Map | About Us

© 1996 Outdoors America Communications
PO Box 609-W, Delta Junction, AK 99737
Tel. (907) 895-4919

forums@outdoorsdirectory.com