Terrain Navigator
CD ROM topographic map coverage for ALL of Alaska

Click for more information

Complete Catalogs

Alaska Hunting Books
Alaska Fishing Books
Alaska Travel Books

Plan Your
Alaska Trip
with The Milepost

Click here for more information or to
order your copy

[ Return to Contents | Post a Reply | Post a new message ]

Rob, you said: "You and those who think like you are the ones that trespass and hunt on private land without permnission elsewhere. You are idiots and lawbreakers."


That, my friend, is an awfully big overgeneralization.  Why is it that we can't have discussions about controversial issues on this forum without resorting to petty name calling?  Idiots and lawbreakers?  That's an awfully big jump.

As for me, I'm not entirely comfortable with the idea of charging different fees for different species.  I am perfectly OK, however, with the landowners charging an access fee.  It's their land and I respect private property laws.  I guess I'm in the grey area between the camps on this issue.  That being said, I feel like I've been lumped in with this group of "lawbreakers and idiots" because I question this practice.  I have never hunted on private land without permission and would never do so.  To make an assumption like that about someone simply because of their philosophical stance is ridiculous.

-Brian

Message Thread:

• Access fee or selling game? GunsmithRob Jan 11 2006
  • Ideas vs people Webmaster Jan 13 2006
    • forgive me, but not entirely a people v idea issue RobR Jan 17 2006
    • Good idea AkHunter45 Jan 13 2006
  • would u prefer they prohibited hunting completely RobR Jan 13 2006
    • not opportunity twodux Jan 13 2006
      • semantics RobR Jan 17 2006
      • Private Land Sheep Hunter Jan 15 2006
    • Right on Rob & mt chignik Jan 13 2006
    • Big assumption B_M Jan 13 2006
      • You said it AkHunter45 Jan 13 2006
        • read the post i was responding to RobR Jan 17 2006
    • Right on RobR martentrapper Jan 13 2006
      • charging twodux Jan 14 2006
      • Afognak timber GunsmithRob Jan 13 2006
      • Native corp AkHunter45 Jan 13 2006
      • prince of wales island muskeg Jan 13 2006
  • So! Why do we have Fedral Fish and wildlife ? Bigmnt Jan 13 2006
    • Constitution PatrickH Jan 13 2006
    • USF&W thenarwhal Jan 13 2006
      • Thanks Thenarwhal Bigmnt Jan 14 2006
      • Dead serious Bigmnt Jan 14 2006
        • feds twodux Jan 14 2006
        • reality muskeg Jan 14 2006
  • Let only the rich hunt! akflyfisher Jan 12 2006
  • The State Does It, Too Mark Jan 11 2006
    • The lower 48 attitudes are creeping up thenarwhal Jan 12 2006
      • scenarios GunsmithRob Jan 12 2006
      • right of retrieval homerdave Jan 12 2006
      • wanton waste? twodux Jan 12 2006
      • Native Land B_M Jan 12 2006
  • attitude homerdave Jan 11 2006
    • game farm attitude Chisana Jan 11 2006
  • Selling Game tccak71 Jan 11 2006
    • Afognak Mr. Pid Jan 11 2006
      • fees for public resources twodux Jan 12 2006
        • trophy fees Mr. Pid Jan 12 2006
          • That's the point B_M Jan 12 2006
            • Fees DPhillips Jan 12 2006
              • Devil's Advocate GunsmithRob Jan 17 2006
              • they do charge twodux Jan 13 2006
                • My Point... DPhillips Jan 13 2006
                  • you DO understand... homerdave Jan 13 2006
                    • ??? DPhillips Jan 13 2006
            • the point Mr. Pid Jan 12 2006
              • what if twodux Jan 14 2006
              • boat launch?? BRWNBR Jan 12 2006
      • Fee's AkHunter45 Jan 11 2006
        • fees Mr. Pid Jan 11 2006
          • Just wrong! Justin Jan 12 2006
          • Land AkHunter45 Jan 11 2006
          • Their LAND - not their game B_M Jan 11 2006
            • agree to disagree Mr. Pid Jan 11 2006
              • the difference twodux Jan 12 2006
            • bitter martentrapper Jan 11 2006
              • Afognak AkHunter45 Jan 11 2006
                • a scam? u got to be kidding RobR Jan 17 2006
                  • yup twodux Jan 17 2006
                    • then about every landowner in the lower 48 ... RobR Jan 18 2006
    • Private Land B_M Jan 11 2006